We asked what you thought, and here's what you had to say -
“Learning
the art of riding is a process ... The crest release is part of the process
as the rider works on perfecting balance with the horse. Executing a crest
release is a means to the end. The wonderful aspect of horsemanship is
that the pursuit of perfection never does end!”
-Sheryl Jordan
Kindred Spirit Horsemanship & Riding
Grantsville
“In responding to whether or not a crest release is important, I believe
that for the ‘beginner’ jumper, it is. It teaches the rider
where to put their hands and helps to keep them off the horse’s mouth.
By learning so early on (hopefully when starting over ground poles), we anticipate
that we will have a very soft and confident rider versus one that is clingy
and grabby. As the rider develops, I let them decide if they still need
to continue to use it or if they prefer to just keep their hands above.
“I have found that most who advance are very strong with their legs and
bodies and, therefore, end up keeping their hands just above and no longer using
and/or needing the crest release. What I have noticed in recent years
is that most beginner fundamentals are no longer taught, so we are seeing more
and more clingy riders holding and grabbing their horses’ mouths at the
schooling and smaller shows. Hopefully, this trend will change back so
that the horses begin to be flowing mounts again instead of going around the
ring with their heads in the air waiting to be hit in the mouth.”
-Kelly McCarley
Camp Letts Equestrian Center
Edgewater
“Having grown up in the days when the accepted equitation style over fences
was a fluid and following hand (‘straight line from the elbow through
the wrist to the bit’), I considered the crest release to be a style
for beginners only. Back in 1965, those in my barn who practiced the
straight line technique were highly resistant to and critical of the crest release.
I don't recall seeing a crest release used by any of the era's top equitation
riders.
“If today's crest release includes riding the neck to the ground,
crutch or not, it makes life easier for both horse and rider. It keeps the rider's
weight off the back and off the mouth with little room for error.
“Many of today's riders are weekend warriors and don't have the daily
conditioning, strength and seat to stay balanced with a soft following
hand over every fence on every course. The crest release affords a sensible
solution for horse and rider.
“What began as a crutch (didn't George Morris invent it for people
who couldn't ride?), has evolved into a legitimate riding technique that
is easy to learn, easy to teach and easy on the horse.”
-Sally L. Harvey
Colora
“There is only one correct technique: the automatic release,
which, in keeping with excellent riding, preserves the straight line between
the elbow and the bit. Unfortunately, only the top few percentage of riders
can perform it successfully. The automatic release takes a tremendous amount
of upper body balance.
“That being said, the crest release is a legitimate riding technique!
To save our horses’ mouths, the crest release allows those riders who
are inexperienced or who do not have the balance it takes to do the automatic
release to jump and compete and even win. Let’s face it: We are not all
‘The Natural.’ The horse would rather have a rider stabilize on
his neck and/or grabbing mane than balancing and banging on his mouth.
I see so many floating hands out there competing that I feel sorry for the horses
and wonder how long they are going to last. In a perfect world, everyone should
learn how to do the automatic release. But we all know the world is not perfect,
and there are limitation[s] in some riders’ abilities. I would not call
the crest release a crutch, but an alternative.”
-Pamela Bartholomew
Whispering Hollow
Forest Hill
“I think the crest release is a valid tool for beginners that hopefully
will keep them from catching the poor horse in the mouth. But there should be
a transition, so that contact can be maintained when moving to a more advanced
riding level. The crest release also tends to encourage getting ahead of
the horse as well. A horse jumping a sizable fence doesn't jump as well, obviously,
with the rider laying on his neck ahead of the motion.”
Nancy Terry
Urbana
“The crest release is a tool needed by those just starting over fences. Even
a rider who has a balanced, strong position in 2-point must get used to the
feel of the horse as he is jumping, particularly at the canter, with an increased
risk of the horse getting to a bad spot. It also lessens the risk of the novice
over fences rider to interfere with the horse's freedom to use his head and
neck. The problem comes if the rider continues using the crest release
long after they should be moving on to a more advanced release, maintaining
contact with the horse’s mouth. Furthermore, today's instructors
should strive to create riders with strong basics and balanced positions that
allow the rider to experience the pure joy of following the horse's mouth and
being one with the horse over the fence as opposed to ‘rushing them through’
to get fast results and a rider who must rely on the crest release to get the
job done.”
-Melanie Gravenor
Still Meadow Farm
Salisbury
“In jumping, all riders need to start with their hands somewhere. It is
far better to do a crest release and not ruin a good horse's mouth, and then
progress to other releases.”
-Margaret Bell
Westminster
“I agree
with what George Morris advocates ... he says the crest release is a very good
technique for beginner and intermediate riders, but advanced riders should strive
for the automatic release, keeping the line from elbow to hand to horse’s
mouth in a straight line. That said, the crest release, if used, should
be done properly. The hands move forward, and press the sides of horse’s
crest, NOT way up next to the mane, or worse,
floating in the air above the neck!”
-Lou Bowling Steinfort
Sandy Spring
“I think a crest release is a mouth saver for most horses, and a very
good idea for a lot of riders learning their balance. I see far too many riders
using the horse’s mouth as a balancing aid just on the flat. The crest
release helps the rider learn balance over fences.”
-Kristina Morris
Fat Chance Farm
Forest Hill
“The way to follow a horse’s mouth is to follow the neck; the
way to follow the neck is to grab the mane; and while the rider slides the hand
up the crest to grab some mane, the rein loosens and loops as the horse jumps.
This can develop into a non-grabbing crest release as the rider learns how that
particular horse uses his neck while jumping.
“The horse wants more than anything to NOT get hit in the mouth when he
jumps. Then he would like to not get hit in the back. Everyone learning
to jump should use the mane/crest as a place to put the hands so they do not
interfere. Everyone should use the mane/crest on a new or young horse
until they learn how that horse jumps. EVERYONE. When the rider cannot
interfere, then they can learn to follow the contact.
“My biggest thing as an instructor is to not unintentionally punish the
horse’s mouth because the rider ‘didn't know’ the horse was
going to jump like that. MAKE SURE by using the mane/crest. Remember, we
are guests up there on that horse. He didn't ask to be ridden or jumped;
that was the human’s idea. So, as the guest, it is the rider’s
job to stay out of the horse’s way so he can do his job. Crutches serve
a good purpose until the user can stand on their own.”
-Kim Meier-Morani
Worton
“I am viewing this solely from the show hunter aspect. Yes, I think
the crest release is a legitimate riding technique. I think the rider should
do whatever he or she has to do to get the best jump out of their horse. After
all, isn’t that what show hunters are judged on? Style!!!! Nothing makes
me happier than to see a horse put in a lovely jump with a big ol’ loop
in the reins. As long as the [rider] isn’t detracting from the overall
picture (i.e. flapping their arms like a chicken), I don’t care what they
have to do to get their horse to jump like Rox Dene.”
-Jessica Lohman
Poolesville
“If used correctly, a legitimate riding technique … if not,
a crutch.”
Jayne Nessif
Huntington Farm
Woodbine
“I think too many people make a big deal out of this. A properly
executed crest release maintains as good a contact with the horse's mouth as
an automatic. I personally like crest releases, since it reduces the possibility
of a slight bobble causing a sudden pull on the horse's mouth, and I think it
is safer – i.e., less [likely] for a horse to suddenly lunge left or right
or to hesitate if a rider bobbles, plus, frankly, a quick grab on the mane if
there's a problem. I absolutely cringe when I see kids attempting to do
automatics in eventing!”
-Wendy M. Hagan
Frederick
“Your
question regarding the crest release is an interesting one. This technique is
a training aid for green riders who are not yet capable of doing an automatic
release. Trainers who have been working with students for years understand the
need for riders not to fall back and or grab the mouth of the horse while jumping.
The crest release, used correctly, can teach the rider to feel the motion of
the horse’s neck while jumping and stay with the motion of the horse.
That rider should work towards learning the long release, short release and
then the automatic release with the help of their trainer. If the rider never
progresses past the crest release, they are not moving forward in their training,
but stuck at one level.”
-Joyce Glover McDonald
Shadowbrook Farm
Gettysburg, Pennsylvania
“I would say that it is a very good thing to learn correctly. To rely
on your hands and pull on the reins is not only bad looking, [it] inhibits your
horse’s full potential of stretching and finding balance. A proper crest
release should be taught as one of the first important steps to a good jumping
technique.”
-Joanna Engstrom-Brown
Kingsville
“The crest release, I believe, is not a legitimate riding technique
for upper level riders or riders that jump higher then 2 feet. If you are a
beginner jumper or training a horse, however, I think that the crest release
is a wonderful ‘crutch.’ I've seen many a horse show where I cringe
for the poor horses’ mouths when the riders, fence after fence, do not
release enough or at all. I have also ridden horses who have trust issues with
this and will not jump at all because of it. I believe that the horse needs
some kind of release, and an ‘ugly’ or improper release is better
and safer then none at all.”
-Emily Milchling
Westminster
“I think that a crest release can be a useful ‘tool’ for teaching
beginner riders how to stay out of their horse's face when jumping. The problem
now is that a) I've seen them way too exaggerated, with the rider practically
laying on top of the horse's neck, which is extremely dangerous; or b) riders
never learn the automatic release. If one relies on keeping one's hands pressed
into the horse's crest for balance, they'll never learn what to do in case they
have to ‘adjust’ their position. So it can become a crutch.”
-Diane Landau
Baltimore
“An invention of instructors to relieve the stress on their school
horses [is] admirable -- that it became a convention parallels counting strides
as opposed to seeing your distances, judging only horses that can make the set
strides as opposed to the fundamental concept of judging horses that are adjusting
strides in order to jump the fences, the demise of the outside course and the
handy hunter, and the birth of the show ring hunter vs. the field hunter.
“Gordon Wright in ‘Learning to Ride, Hunt, and Show,’ my edition published in 1966, introduces the crest release as Elementary Jumping. George Morris was -- and still is -- a great student of Gordon Wright, but he clearly took the crest release into the show ring with his students seeing that the horse that is properly schooled and not interfered with will get around nicely -- particularly over related distances -- Ta-Da -- today's Amateur Divisions.
“[There’s a] lot to be said for the business of horse showing that
has evolved around
this concept, though. But is it horsemanship and advanced equitation? Doubt
it.”
-Bonnie Kepner
Williamsport
“I do not think the crest release is the most effective jumping method. I
feel that it is just used as a crutch to first teach someone who is inexperienced
how to jump. However, I have seen the crest release effectively used,
but I find other methods deemed to be more successful.”
-Aviva Brown
Pasadena
“Quoting from ‘Hunt Seat Equitation’ by George H.
Morris, 1971, with a foreword by A. Eugene Cunningham, Warrenton, Virginia:
‘The most important single factor in jumping an actual fence is the release
of the horse's mouth on approaching the obstacle … Not only does this
release allow a horse to increase his pace, but it also allows him to use his
head and neck in flight over an obstacle. This basic principle is so much
the most important first step in actually negotiating a jump that without its
proper use and understanding, no further progress can be made.’
“See 4/28/06 The Chronicle, page 13 -- lovely form! Most of
the event and timber riders are so in synch with their horses, while so many
of the show riders have quite different form, making it hard or impossible for
their mount to properly use its head and neck.”
-Kinko Hackney
Parkton
“P.S. -- My apologies -- when I responded, I had just seen the picture
in The Chronicle.
But the cover of The Equiery has a really good and big picture.”
If you didn't have a chance to respond before we went to press, send us your thoughts to info@equiery.com, and we will add them.
Copyright ©2006 The Equiery/Tuttle Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved.